American Express® Blue Cash Preferred® Card vs Hilton Honors American Express Surpass® Card

American Express® Blue Cash Preferred® Card earns more in 4 of the 7 categories we track. American Express® Blue Cash Preferred® Card has the lower annual fee.

The basics

Detail
Annual fee$95$150
Card typePersonalPersonal
RewardsCash BackHilton Honors Points
Each point is worth1.00¢0.40¢
Everywhere else1x3x
Welcome bonus$250 after $3,000 in 180 days130,000 Hilton Honors Points + Free Night Reward after $3,000 in 6 months (through Jan 13, 2027)

What each earns

CategoryAmerican Express® Blue Cash Preferred® CardHilton Honors American Express Surpass® Card
Groceries
6.0% (higher)
6x, capped spending, up to $6,000
2.4%
6x
Streaming
6.0% (higher)
6x
1.2%
3x
Gas Stations
3.0% (higher)
3x
2.4%
6x
Rideshare & Transit
3.0% (higher)
3x
1.2%
3x
Dining & Restaurants
1.0%
1x
2.4% (higher)
6x
Amazon & Online Shopping
1.0%
1x
1.6% (higher)
4x
Everything else
1.0%
1x
1.2% (higher)
3x

Returns are the points per dollar times what a point is worth, using your smart setting. Caps and rotating categories change what you actually earn. How we value rewards

The better question is which one adds more to the cards you already have.

Ask the advisor